The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe
Executive presence is the critique that appears without any instruction sheet attached. Someone says you need more of it, no one can explain what it looks like, and you begin second-guessing your jacket. Pause there. Whoever is evaluating you is weighing three things: whether they would hand you a decision, whether your words land when you talk, and whether you keep your footing when things go sideways. Your wardrobe is not on that list. The fuzziness is no accident. Studies on the likability penalty have repeatedly shown that the same request sounds assertive coming from a man and pushy coming from a woman, and "presence" is the convenient place for that bias to hide.
The self-assessment
Looking back across the last four weeks, respond with a plain yes or no to each item. Tally only the moments that actually happened, leaving aside the ones you hope you would have handled well.
1. When you offer a recommendation, you state the recommendation first and the logic afterward.
2. During a meeting, you voiced a clear objection to a colleague who holds more seniority than you.
3. Could you explain your team's purpose in one line that a stranger from Parma or Lakewood would understand right away?
4. When a problem surfaces, people bring it to you before they take it elsewhere.
5. In conversation, you let a silence stretch out rather than scrambling to fill it right away.
6. You said "I don't know yet, but I'll have an answer by Thursday," and then you delivered it.
7. Your notes to senior leaders run shorter than the ones they send you.
8. You declined a senior request and gave your reason in one clear sentence.
9. Even as the room around you grew unsettled, you kept your poise intact.
Step ten. A phrase of yours came back to you, repeated by someone else, in a later meeting.
Interpreting your result
Eight to ten: established presence. People in the room, from Shaker Heights to Euclid, already treat you as the person who decides. If you still receive the feedback, find out who is offering it and what they really mean, since it may have little to do with you.
Four to seven: growing. Your judgment and some of the signals are in place. What is mostly missing is pace and economy: leading with the recommendation, writing the shorter note, leaving the silence alone while the room catches up.
Zero to three: capable but understated. You are doing the work and letting others decide what it signifies. That is not a personal failing. Many of us were trained to walk through our reasoning before reaching a conclusion, and that was sound advice for the classroom, not the boardroom.
Next steps
Eight to ten: the next time someone mentions "presence," ask, "What specifically would you like to see differently in the next meeting?" Note the answer. If nothing comes back, you have learned something about the feedback itself.
Four to seven: for one month, open every update with the decision you need in the opening sentence. Make no other changes. Notice how the room reacts.
Zero to three: at your next meeting, disagree once, briefly, with the most senior person present, and then stop speaking. A single line such as "I see it differently, and here's why" is all you need, and then you hand the floor to them. The quiet that follows is the presence.
Tally your yeses, then share this with the woman in Medina or Strongsville who was told she lacks presence without anyone explaining what they meant.