Four things to negotiate before you sign, including the one HR hopes you won't notice
Think of a severance offer as an opening bid rather than the last word. What the company is really buying is your signature on a release of claims, and it has set that price at the smallest figure it believes you will take. An AARP survey from 2026 reported that 64% of workers over 50 have experienced age discrimination on the job. That is part of why the release is the document HR most wants signed quickly and least wants you to question.
You have every right to push back on it. Workers past age 40 receive a federally protected period in which they can look the agreement over before deciding. Take the whole window, and work through the checklist below before answering anyone.
Your checklist for review
Mark each item in the offer that sits in your inbox as yes or no.
1. Your severance pay exceeds the company's usual formula, or you have asked to see that formula.
2. The company covers your health insurance for a specified period, rather than just letting you buy into the plan at your own cost.
3. Whether your current-year bonus comes in full or gets prorated is spelled out in the letter, so check that line closely.
4. Any unvested stock or retention money that would have vested in the coming months is accelerated or paid now.
5. The separation date is one that suits you, not only one that fits the company's headcount report.
6. The reason for leaving is worded so it won't hold back your next job search, such as "position eliminated."
7. The non-disparagement language binds the company just as it binds you, which is worth confirming in the text.
8. Any non-compete or non-solicitation term is narrow enough to let you take the role you are most likely to land next.
9. Among the terms, you may find outplacement help, a reference letter, or a pre-agreed script for references.
Final step Before you sign, either a lawyer has already gone over the release of claims or you intend to have one do so.
Reading your outcome
A score of 0 to 3 means the offer you received is the company's boilerplate form. Nobody built this offer around your situation, and that includes the dollar figure. That is not a criticism. Expect it as a first offer, one built to be pushed back on and improved.
4 to 7: Part of the package was negotiated, possibly by whoever left before you. Because the shortfalls are concrete, you can point to each of them in Cleveland, and that makes them hard for the company to brush aside.
A score of 8 to 10 signals a package that holds up well. Your task now is to protect it: make sure every term appears in the signed version, and use your review period to read the release closely rather than to celebrate.
Your next steps
With a 0 to 3 score, a single email covering four asks works best: more weeks of pay, company-covered health insurance for a set period, the prorated bonus, and a non-disparagement clause that runs both ways. You might open with, "I appreciate you sending this over. Before I sign, I'd like to go over four items." Companies in Greater Cleveland and across Ohio budget for this kind of conversation, and HR usually expects it.
When your score lands between 4 and 7, pick the two no answers that matter most and name each one in your request. Naming a particular item usually brings a quicker reply than voicing a broad grievance.
A score of 8 to 10 calls for a lawyer, ideally one in Northeast Ohio or Greater Cleveland, to check the release and any restrictive covenants. The provision most likely to slip past you is frequently the non-compete, because a sweeping one costs the employer little yet can block your next job.
Consider sharing your score anonymously with the women in our network who may face this next. A good number of them presume that the initial figure is set in stone.